[Pro] 8 19 inch 4-bay rack NAS Review: Opslag voor het rek

Frank Everaardt 3 mei 2014 05:59

8 besproken producten

Inhoudsopgave

Vergelijkingstabel

Algemeen

Merk	Asustor	Lenovo	Lenovo	Netgear	QNAP	Seagate	Synology	Thecus
Productnaam	AS-604RD	EMC px4-300r	EMC px4-400r	ReadyNAS 2120	TS-470U-RP	STDN200	RackStation RS814	N4510U-S Pro
Productcode	AS-604RD	70BJ9003WW	70CK9000WW	RN2120	TS-470U-RP	STDN200	RS814	N4510U-S PRO
Details	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo	Productinfo
Bays / Harddisks
Aantal interne drive bays	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)	4 bay(s)
Aantal voorgeïnstalleerde harddisks	0				0	0
Totale capaciteit meegeleverde harddisks	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB	0 GB
Harddisk interface	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA	Serial ATA
Harddisks afmeting	2.5 of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch	2.5 of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch	2.5 en/of 3.5 inch
Hot-swap drive bays
CPU / geheugen
Processorfamilie	Intel Atom	Intel Celeron	Intel Atom	Marvell Armada	Intel Celeron	Intel Atom		Intel Atom
Processortype	Intel Atom D2700	Intel Celeron E1500	Intel Atom D2700	Marvell Armada XP	Intel Celeron G1620	Intel Atom D2700	Marvell Armada XP	Intel Atom D2700
Processorsnelheid	2.13 GHz	2.2 GHz	2.13 GHz	1.2 GHz	2.7 GHz	2.13 GHz	1.33 GHz	2.13 GHz
Processorcores		2 cores	2 cores	2 cores	2 cores	2 cores	2 cores	2 cores
Werkgeheugen	1024 MB	2000 MB	2000 MB	2000 MB	2048 MB	2048 MB	1000 MB	2048 MB
Werkgeheugen uitbreidbaar
Aansluitingen
USB interface voor peripherals								4
LAN 1	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s
LAN 2	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s	1000 Mbit/s
LAN 3					1000 Mbit/s
LAN 4					1000 Mbit/s
HDMI
Geïntegreerde switch (poorten)
eSATA aansluiting	2	0	1	2		1	1	1
Wireless LAN
USB 2.0 poorten (totaal)	4	3	4	1	5	3		4
USB 3.0 (USB 3.1 Gen 1) poorten (totaal)	2	0	1	2	4	2	2	2
USB-aansluitingen voor (totaal)		1	1	1	1	1		2
USB-aansluitingen achter (totaal)		2	4	2	8	4		4
USB 3.0 voor		0	1	0	0	0		2
USB 3.0 achter		0	0	2	4	2		0
RAID
RAID 0
RAID 1
RAID 5
RAID 6
RAID 10
JBOD
Hot-spare functionaliteit
Knoppen
Reset
USB-sync
USB-eject
Power
Fan
Lampjes / Display
Power
Status
Error
Capaciteit
USB activity
LAN activity
HDD activity
Eigenschappen
Diepte	51.3 cm	52.7 cm	52.7 cm	30.8 cm	47.6 cm	38.3 cm	45.75 cm	55.5 cm
Breedte	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm	43.5 cm
Hoogte	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm	4.4 cm
Kensington aansluiting
Printserver
Webadmin
Authenticatie m.b.v. gebruikers
Authenticatie m.b.v. gebruikersgroepen
Authenticatie m.b.v. wachtwoorden op shares
Read-only toegang mogelijk
FTP server
FTP server met anonymous
Aparte gebruikers voor FTP
UPnP compatible
HTTP folders
DHCP server
Active Directory Support
Apple file server
iTunes server
DLNA (UPnP AV) server
NDAS / Zetera (directe schijf toegang)
Mionet
Multimedia Server
Download	bittorent, newsgroups	bittorent	bittorent	bittorent	bittorent,ftp,http	http,ftp,bittorent	bittorent, newsgroups	bittorent
Webserver	apache	apache	apache	apache	apache		apache	apache
FTP/HTTP Download
Torrent Client
iSCSI ondersteuning
Access Control List (ACL)
Maximaal ondersteunde opslagcapaciteit			16 TB	16 TB		16 TB	16 TB	16 TB
Opgegeven stroomverbruik	31.6 W			38 W	58.5 W	180 W	42 W	16.2 W
Actieve koeling (fan)
2014 NAS Benchmarks
Intel NASPT - HD Video Playback - 1 Disk	93.9 MB/s	74.2 MB/s	86.4 MB/s	77.2 MB/s	102.78 MB/s	79.1 MB/s	93.9 MB/s	85 MB/s
Intel NASPT - 2x HD Playback - 1 Disk	106.9 MB/s	69.8 MB/s	87.2 MB/s	95.9 MB/s	111.2 MB/s	68.5 MB/s	107 MB/s	95.9 MB/s
Intel NASPT - 4x HD Playback - 1 Disk	114.6 MB/s	73 2 MB/s	82.2 MB/s	94.6 MB/s	111.9 MB/s	71.6 MB/s	115.3 MB/s	99 MB/s
Intel NASPT - HD Video Record - 1 Disk	111.4 MB/s	97.9 MB/s	106.4 MB/s	87.2 MB/s	101.4 MB/s	123.4 MB/s	116.3 MB/s	105.4 MB/s
Intel NASPT - HD Playback and Record - 1 Disk	91 MB/s	79 MB/s	102.5 MB/s	78.1 MB/s	107.8 MB/s	88.5 MB/s	96.7 MB/s	82.3 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Content Creation - 1 Disk	8.9 MB/s	11.1 MB/s	11.2 MB/s	9.5 MB/s	9.4 MB/s	11.3 MB/s	11.3 MB/s	9.3 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Office Productivity - 1 Disk	52 MB/s	50 MB/s	48.3 MB/s	46.4 MB/s	51.4 MB/s	51.5 MB/s	51.6 MB/s	53.1 MB/s
Intel NASPT - File copy to NAS - 1 Disk	118.2 MB/s	118 MB/s	111.9 MB/s	87.2 MB/s	95.8 MB/s	124.9 MB/s	130.1 MB/s	108.7 MB/s
Intel NASPT - File copy from NAS - 1 Disk	83.1 MB/s	74.7 MB/s	75 MB/s	62.9 MB/s	92.3 MB/s	74.8 MB/s	85.5 MB/s	81.4 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Dir copy to NAS - 1 Disk	18.8 MB/s	20.2 MB/s	11.7 MB/s	3.1 MB/s	24.4 MB/s	20 MB/s	18.8 MB/s	22.2 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Dir copy from NAS - 1 Disk	23.4 MB/s	22.7 MB/s	11.2 MB/s	10.1 MB/s	25.8 MB/s	12 MB/s	23.1 MB/s	25.4 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Photo Album - 1 Disk	12.9 MB/s	12.6 MB/s	9.6 MB/s	9.8 MB/s	14.4 MB/s	12.9 MB/s	12.5 MB/s	12.2 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Gemiddelde doorvoersnelheid - 1 disk	69.6 MB/s	58.6 MB/s	62 MB/s	55.2 MB/s	70.7 MB/s	61.5 MB/s	71.8 MB/s	65 MB/s
Intel NASPT - HD Video Playback - 4 Disk RAID 5	89.5 MB/s	79.5 MB/s	92.5 MB/s	82.45 MB/s	95.6 MB/s	89 MB/s	95.1 MB/s	93.8 MB/s
Intel NASPT - 2x HD Playback - 4 Disk RAID 5	105.7 MB/s	101.3 MB/s	101.6 MB/s	84.6 MB/s	106.7 MB/s	110.5 MB/s	112 MB/s	106.5 MB/s
Intel NASPT - 4x HD Playback - 4 Disk RAID 5	116.3 MB/s	98.2 MB/s	101.9 MB/s	92 MB/s	107.1 MB/s	116.1 MB/s	114.6 MB/s	115.8 MB/s
Intel NASPT - HD Video Record - 4 Disk RAID 5	105.8 MB/s	111 MB/s	102.3 MB/s	93.1 MB/s	69.6 MB/s	122 MB/s	116.2 MB/s	108.8 MB/s
Intel NASPT - HD Playback and Record - 4 Disk RAID 5	90.4 MB/s	94.8 MB/s	103.4 MB/s	61.1 MB/s	97.3 MB/s	66.4 MB/s	109.1 MB/s	58.5 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Content Creation - 4 Disk RAID 5	8.8 MB/s	9.8 MB/s	9.9 MB/s	6.6 MB/s	6.3 MB/s	11.2 MB/s	12.8 MB/s	6.9 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Office Productivity - 4 Disk RAID 5	49.9 MB/s	50.8 MB/s	48 MB/s	42.6 MB/s	42.2 MB/s	52.2 MB/s	50.4 MB/s	49.6 MB/s
Intel NASPT - File copy to NAS - 4 Disk RAID 5	112.7 MB/s	116.5 MB/s	107.1 MB/s	55.6 MB/s	82.1 MB/s	126.3 MB/s	119 MB/s	113 MB/s
Intel NASPT - File copy from NAS - 4 Disk RAID 5	86.9 MB/s	83.3 MB/s	82.8 MB/s	71.1 MB/s	86.7 MB/s	87.7 MB/s	78.8 MB/s	83.6 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Dir copy to NAS - 4 Disk RAID 5	19.6 MB/s	16.3 MB/s	10.4 MB/s	2.6 MB/s	20 MB/s	19.1 MB/s	21 MB/s	17.2 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Dir copy from NAS - 4 Disk RAID 5	21.7 MB/s	21.5 MB/s	14.5 MB/s	8.8 MB/s	10.1 MB/s	23.3 MB/s	22.7 MB/s	24.2 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Photo Album - 4 Disk RAID 5	11.9 MB/s	14 MB/s	10.5 MB/s	9.8 MB/s	10.9 MB/s	14.1 MB/s	10 MB/s	12.1 MB/s
Intel NASPT - Gemiddelde doorvoersnelheid - 4 disk RAID 5	68.3 MB/s	66.4 MB/s	65.4 MB/s	50.9 MB/s	61.2 MB/s	69.8 MB/s	71.8 MB/s	65.8 MB/s
10 GB write 1-disk	102.79 MB/s	108.19 MB/s	100.82 MB/s	52.41 MB/s	96.14 MB/s	109.89 MB/s	105.1 MB/s	109.5 MB/s
10 GB read 1-disk	110.43 MB/s	97.36 MB/s	105.13 MB/s	98.1 MB/s	110.02 MB/s	96.68 MB/s	106.1 MB/s	112.52 MB/s
10 GB write 4-disk RAID 5	102.32 MB/s	98.55 MB/s	109.47 MB/s	42.75 MB/s	98.56 MB/s	99.59 MB/s	106.02 MB/s	76.46 MB/s
10 GB read 4-disk RAID 5	110.34 MB/s	108.54 MB/s	113.07 MB/s	81.9 MB/s	99.88 MB/s	111.88 MB/s	102.92 MB/s	111.18 MB/s
Intel NASPT Totaal - 1 Disk	835.1 MB/s	703.2 MB/s	743.6 MB/s	662 MB/s	848.58 MB/s	738.5 MB/s	862.1 MB/s	779.9 MB/s
Intel NASPT Totaal - 4 Disk RAID 5	819.2 MB/s	797 MB/s	784.9 MB/s	610.35 MB/s	734.6 MB/s	837.9 MB/s	861.7 MB/s	790 MB/s
2014 NAS Benchmarks (2x 1 Gb)
10 GB write 2x1-disk totaal	111.6 MB/s	154.01 MB/s	130.21 MB/s	63.77 MB/s	179.26 MB/s	183.49 MB/s	163.32 MB/s	186.81 MB/s
10 GB read 2x1-disk totaal	222.11 MB/s	190.76 MB/s	150.26 MB/s	126.29 MB/s	222.34 MB/s	207.2 MB/s	188.15 MB/s	222.57 MB/s
10 GB write 4-disk totaal RAID 5	104.7 MB/s	117.34 MB/s	108.93 MB/s	57.85 MB/s	127.42 MB/s	78 MB/s	98.3 MB/s	139.72 MB/s
10 GB read 4-disk totaal RAID 5	198.41 MB/s	172.52 MB/s	154.65 MB/s	116.74 MB/s	222.43 MB/s	217.11 MB/s	156.09 MB/s	199.69 MB/s
2014 NAS Benchmarks (4x 1 Gb)
10 GB write - 4x1 disk totaal					288.53 MB/s
10 GB read - 4x1 disk totaal					442.3 MB/s
10 GB write - 4 disk totaal RAID 5					122.77 MB/s
10 GB read - 5 disk totaal RAID 5					270.34 MB/s
2014 NAS Benchmarks Stroomverbruik
Stroomverbruik - Rust (disk draait) 1x Seagate 4 TB NAS HDD	43 W	63 W	26.90 W	21.7 W	45.6 W	25.6 W	21.4 W	35 W
Stroomverbruik - Actief 1x Seagate 4 TB NAS HDD	50.9 W	72.2 W	30.4 W	25.4 W	51.2 W	29.1 W	25.2 W	38.9 W
Stroomverbruik - Rust (disks draaien) 4x Seagate 4 TB NAS HD	63.8 W	69.2 W	40.2 W	37 W	64.9 W	42.9 W	37.9 W	49.5 W
Stroomverbruik - Actief 4x Seagate 4 TB NAS HDD	72 W	88.9 W	49.9 W	41.9 W	72.9 W	47.9 W	43 W	58.6 W

Advertentie

8 besproken producten

Vergelijk alle producten

Vergelijk		Product	Prijs
		Asustor AS-604RD 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 of 3.5 inch Intel Atom D2700 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Lenovo EMC px4-300r 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Intel Celeron E1500 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Lenovo EMC px4-400r 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Intel Atom D2700 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Netgear ReadyNAS 2120 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Marvell Armada XP 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		QNAP TS-470U-RP 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Intel Celeron G1620 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Seagate STDN200 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 of 3.5 inch Intel Atom D2700 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Synology RackStation RS814 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Marvell Armada XP 1000 Mbit/s Wireless LAN	Niet verkrijgbaar
		Thecus N4510U-S Pro 4 bay(s) 0 GB 2.5 en/of 3.5 inch Intel Atom D2700 1000 Mbit/s	Niet verkrijgbaar

0