nVidia GeForce GTS 450 review

XWB 13 september 2010 09:29
2 besproken producten
Inhoudsopgave
  1. 1. Inleiding
  2. 2. GF106
  3. 3. MSI N450GTS Cyclone OC
  4. 4. Concurrentie
  5. 5. Benchmarks
  6. 6. 3DMark Vantage
  7. 7. Heaven 2.0 (DirectX 11)
  8. 8. Aliens versus Predator (DirectX 11)
  9. 9. DiRT 2 (DirectX 11)
  10. 10. Just Cause 2 (DirectX 10)
  11. 11. Far Cry 2 (DirectX 10)
  12. 12. Metro 2033 (DirectX 11)
  13. 13. Resident Evil 5 (DirectX 10)
  14. 14. S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat (DirectX 11)
  15. 15. Street Fighter IV (DirectX 9)
  16. 16. Tom Clancy's HAWX (DirectX 10.1)
  17. 17. Stroomverbruik
  18. 18. Radeon HD 5770 vs. GeForce GTS 450
  19. 19. Testresultaten MSI
  20. 20. Conclusie
  21. 2 besproken producten

Radeon HD 5770 vs. GeForce GTS 450

We schreven al dat de GeForce GTS 450 qua prijsstelling vrijwel identiek is aan de Radeon HD 5770. Tijd dus om de balans op te maken: in onderstaande tabel zie je alle benchmarks van beide kaarten nog eens overzichtelijk onder elkaar, met in de laatste kolom het procentuele verschil. Onderaan de tabel vind je de gemiddelde verschil: de GeForce GTS 450 blijkt in onze benchmarks gemiddeld 8,7% langzamer te zijn dan de Radeon HD 5770. Dat valt ons toch eigenlijk een klein beetje tegen...

Benchmark Radeon HD 5770 GeForce GTS 450 GTS 450 vs. HD 5770
3DMark Vantage (Performance) 11200 10566 -5,7%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 No tesselation] 31,1 fps 30,2 fps -2,9%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 Normal tesselation] 22,0 fps 22,1 fps 0,5%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 Extreme tesselation] 14,7 fps 15,9 fps 8,2%
Far Cry 2 [1680x1050 - Very High] 67,6 fps 63,3 fps -6,4%
Far Cry 2 [1680x1050 4xAA - Very High] 47,8 fps 51,0 fps 6,7%
Far Cry 2 [1920x1080 - Very High] 60,5 fps 57,2 fps -5,5%
Far Cry 2 [1920x1080 4xAA - Very High] 42,8 fps 45,8 fps 7,0%
Resident Evil 5 [1680x1050 - High] 76,6 fps 72,3 fps -5,6%
Resident Evil 5 [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 72,1 fps 63,6 fps -11,8%
Resident Evil 5 [1920x1080 - High] 68,8 fps 63,6 fps -7,6%
Resident Evil 5 [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 64,7 fps 55,7 fps -13,9%
Street Fighter 4 [1680x1050 - High] 151,5 fps 139,6 fps -7,9%
Street Fighter 4 [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 72,7 fps 101,8 fps 40,0%
Street Fighter 4 [1920x1080 - High] 137,2 fps 124,1 fps -9,5%
Street Fighter 4 [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 64,8 fps 90,8 fps 40,1%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1680x1050 - High] 73,0 fps 65,0 fps -11,0%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 60,0 fps 56,0 fps -6,7%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1920x1080 - High] 67,0 fps 58,0 fps -13,4%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 55,0 fps 48,0 fps -12,7%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1680x1050 Extreme] 49,0 fps 42,0 fps -14,3%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1680x1050 4x AA Extreme] 24,0 fps 20,0 fps -16,7%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1920x1080 Extreme] 43,0 fps 36,0 fps -16,3%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1920x1080 4x AA Extreme] 21,0 fps 17,0 fps -19,0%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1680x1050, Normal] 23,4 fps 20,7 fps -11,5%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1680x1050, Very High] 15,6 fps 13,0 fps -16,7%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1920x1080, Normal] 19,9 fps 18,3 fps -8,0%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1920x1080, Very High] 13,6 fps 11,3 fps -16,9%
Just Cause 2 [1680x1050, Very High, 0x/16x] 42,0 fps 23,9 fps -43,1%
Just Cause 2 [1680x1050, Very High, 4x/16x] 32,0 fps 21,7 fps -32,2%
Just Cause 2 [1920x1080, Very High, 0x/16x] 37,0 fps 21,6 fps -41,6%
Just Cause 2 [1920x1080, Very High, 4x/16x] 29,0 fps 19,2 fps -33,8%
DiRT 2 [1680x1050, 0x AA - Ultra High] 50,2 fps 53,7 fps 7,0%
DiRT 2 [1680x1050, 4x AA - Ultra High] 45,3 fps 47,0 fps 3,8%
DiRT 2 [1920x1080, 0x AA - Ultra High] 42,2 fps 48,4 fps 14,7%
DiRT 2 [1920x1080, 4x AA - Ultra High] 47,7 fps 42,8 fps -10,3%
AvP DX11 [1680x1050, 0x AA - Very High] 35,6 fps 27,2 fps -23,6%
AvP DX11 [1680x1050, 4x AA - Very High] 20,6 fps 17,8 fps -13,6%
AvP DX11 [1920x1080, 0x AA - Very High] 31,5 fps 24,1 fps -23,5%
AvP DX11 [1920x1080, 4x AA - Very High] 18,2 fps 15,8 fps -13,2%
Gemiddeld - - -8,7%

Wat nu als nVidia haar prijzen de komende dagen nog scherper zu maken, waardoor de GTS 450 eigenlijk rechtstreeks tegenover de Radeon HD 5750 wordt gepositioneerd? Dan worden de rollen, zoals in onderstaande tabel te zien, exact omgedraaid: nVidia's nieuwe kaart blijkt dan 8,6% sneller. Opnieuw overigens niet bepaald een wereldschokkend verschil.

Benchmark Radeon HD 5750 GeForce GTS 450 GTS 450 vs. HD 5750
3DMark Vantage (Performance) 9241 10566 14,3%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 No tesselation] 26,4 fps 30,2 fps 14,4%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 Normal tesselation] 18,5 fps 22,1 fps 19,5%
Heaven 2.0 DX11 [1920x1080 Extreme tesselation] 12,4 fps 15,9 fps 28,2%
Far Cry 2 [1680x1050 - Very High] 55,9 fps 63,3 fps 13,2%
Far Cry 2 [1680x1050 4xAA - Very High] 41,9 fps 51,0 fps 21,7%
Far Cry 2 [1920x1080 - Very High] 50,5 fps 57,2 fps 13,3%
Far Cry 2 [1920x1080 4xAA - Very High] 37,4 fps 45,8 fps 22,5%
Resident Evil 5 [1680x1050 - High] 65,1 fps 72,3 fps 11,1%
Resident Evil 5 [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 62,3 fps 63,6 fps 2,1%
Resident Evil 5 [1920x1080 - High] 58,2 fps 63,6 fps 9,3%
Resident Evil 5 [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 55,8 fps 55,7 fps -0,2%
Street Fighter 4 [1680x1050 - High] 128,4 fps 139,6 fps 8,7%
Street Fighter 4 [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 62,8 fps 101,8 fps 62,1%
Street Fighter 4 [1920x1080 - High] 116,3 fps 124,1 fps 6,7%
Street Fighter 4 [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 55,9 fps 90,8 fps 62,4%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1680x1050 - High] 51,0 fps 65,0 fps 27,5%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1680x1050 4xAA - High] 44,0 fps 56,0 fps 27,3%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1920x1080 - High] 46,0 fps 58,0 fps 26,1%
Tom Clancy's HAWX DX10(.1) [1920x1080 4xAA - High] 40,0 fps 48,0 fps 20,0%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1680x1050 Extreme] 40,0 fps 42,0 fps 5,0%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1680x1050 4x AA Extreme] 20,0 fps 20,0 fps 0,0%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1920x1080 Extreme] 34,0 fps 36,0 fps 5,9%
S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Call of Pripyat [1920x1080 4x AA Extreme] 17,0 fps 17,0 fps 0,0%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1680x1050, Normal] 21,3 fps 20,7 fps -2,8%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1680x1050, Very High] 13,3 fps 13,0 fps -2,3%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1920x1080, Normal] 19,0 fps 18,3 fps -3,7%
Metro 2033 DX11 [1920x1080, Very High] 11,3 fps 11,3 fps 0,0%
Just Cause 2 [1680x1050, Very High, 0x/16x] 35,3 fps 23,9 fps -32,3%
Just Cause 2 [1680x1050, Very High, 4x/16x] 28,1 fps 21,7 fps -22,8%
Just Cause 2 [1920x1080, Very High, 0x/16x] 31,6 fps 21,6 fps -31,6%
Just Cause 2 [1920x1080, Very High, 4x/16x] 25,2 fps 19,2 fps -23,8%
DiRT 2 [1680x1050, 0x AA - Ultra High] 46,6 fps 53,7 fps 15,2%
DiRT 2 [1680x1050, 4x AA - Ultra High] 43,4 fps 47,0 fps 8,3%
DiRT 2 [1920x1080, 0x AA - Ultra High] 43,3 fps 48,4 fps 11,8%
DiRT 2 [1920x1080, 4x AA - Ultra High] 40,5 fps 42,8 fps 5,7%
AvP DX11 [1680x1050, 0x AA - Very High] 28,2 fps 27,2 fps -3,5%
AvP DX11 [1680x1050, 4x AA - Very High] 17,1 fps 17,8 fps 4,1%
AvP DX11 [1920x1080, 0x AA - Very High] 25,0 fps 24,1 fps -3,6%
AvP DX11 [1920x1080, 4x AA - Very High] 15,2 fps 15,8 fps 3,9%
Gemiddeld - - 8,6%
Volgende pagina: 19. Testresultaten MSI
Advertentie

2 besproken producten

Vergelijk   Product Prijs
MSI N450GTS Cyclone OC 1GB

MSI N450GTS Cyclone OC 1GB

  • Nvidia GeForce GTS 450
  • 1024 MB
 Niet verkrijgbaar
Nvidia GeForce GTS 450

Nvidia GeForce GTS 450

  • GF106
  • 192 cores
  • 783 MHz
  • 1024 MB
  • 128 bit
  • DirectX 12 fl 11_0
  • PCI-Express 2.0 x16
 Niet verkrijgbaar

Bekijk ook deze 3d-chip artikelen op Hardware Info

0