Vergelijkingstabel
In de onderstaande vergelijkingstabel zijn de testresultaten en belangrijke eigenschappen van de besproken branders naast elkaar gezet. Om een betere onderlinge vergelijking te maken is de tabel verder uitgebreid met een aantal reeds eerder geteste branders.
| Acer CRW2010A | ASUS CRW-2410S | HP CD-Writer CD24ri | LiteOn LTR-24102B | Plextor24/10/40A | Plextor 16/10/40A | Waitec Megalus | Waitec T-Rex | Yamaha CRW2100E | |
| Opgegeven snelheid | 20/10/40 | 24/10/40 | 24/10/40 | 24/10/40 | 24/10/40 | 16/10/40 | 24/10/40 | 16/10/40 | 16/10/40 |
| Aansluiting | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | Atapi / IDE | SCSI | Atapi / IDE |
| Binnenwerk | Acer | Sanyo | Sanyo | Mediatek | Sanyo | Sanyo | Sanyo | Sanyo | Yamaha |
| Buffer | 2 MB | 2 MB | 4 MB | 2 MB | 4 MB | 2 MB | 2 MB | 2 MB | 8 MB |
| Firmwareversie | H.HF | 6z35 | 2.00 | 5s01 | 1.00 | 1.00 | 6.34 | 4.27 | 1.0D |
| Brandsnelheden | |||||||||
| Gemiddeld | 16,90X | 22,77X | 22,77 X | 22,74X | 22,70X | 16,00X | 22,30X | 16,00X | 15,38X |
| Beginsnelheid | 11,99X | 16,00X | 16,00 X | 16,06X | 16,01X | 16,00X | 16,01X | 16,00X | 12,10X |
| Eindsnelheid | 20,01X | 24,31X | 24,03 X | 24,10X | 24,01X | 16,00X | 24,00X | 16,00X | 15,78X |
| Type CLV/CAV | Z-CLV | Z-CLV | Z-CLV | Z-CLV | Z-CLV | CLV | Z-CLV | CLV | P-CAV |
| BURN-proof/Just Link/Seamless Link | Seamless Link | BURN-Proof | BURN-proof | SMART-Burn | BURN-proof | BURN-proof | BURN-proof | BURN-proof | Nee |
| Kwaliteit van CDR's bepalen | Nee | FlexSS | PoweRec II | Smart-X | PoweRec II | Nee, alleen met Firmware-update | Nee | Nee | Nee |
| 90 CD's branden | Nee, tot 83 minuten | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Nee |
| CD text | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja | Ja |
| RAW-mode | Ja | Ja | Nee | Ja | Nee | Nee | Ja | Ja | Nee |
| Leessnelheden data CD | |||||||||
| Gemiddeld | 28,80X | 30,13X | 31,24 X | 29,69X | 30,63X | 30,69X | 30,13X | 30,06X | 28,00X |
| Beginsnelheid | 17,77X | 18,50X | 18,46X | 18,31X | 18,89X | 18,93X | 18,58X | 18,59X | 17,22X |
| Eindsnelheid | 37,61X | 39,95X | 41,23 X | 38,78X | 39,99X | 40,08X | 39,36X | 39,08X | 36,60X |
| Type CLV/CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV |
| CPU gebruik (data CD) | |||||||||
| 1X | 3% | 1% | 1% | 1% | 0 | 1% | 1% | 1% | 1% |
| 2X | 6% | 2% | 2% | 2% | 1 | 2% | 3% | 2% | 2% |
| 4X | 18% | 5% | 5% | 4% | 3 | 5% | 7% | 5% | 9% |
| 8X | 46% | 11% | 10% | 7% | 6 | 10% | 14% | 9% | 8% |
| Zoektijden (data CD) | |||||||||
| Random | 92 ms | 123 ms | 108 ms | 85 ms | 135 ms | 145 ms | 125 ms | 133 ms | 127 ms |
| 1/3 | 88 ms | 127 ms | 133 ms | 93 ms | 154 ms | 160 ms | 130 ms | 141 ms | 142 ms |
| full | 153 ms | 239 ms | 216 ms | 155 ms | 247 ms | 307 ms | 244 ms | 256 ms | 197 ms |
| DAE snelheden | |||||||||
| Gemiddeld | 17,79X | 30,31X | 32,30 X | 25,62X | 32,31X | 32,57X | 31,83X | 25,29X | 26,06X |
| Beginsnelheid | 11,98X | 17,91X | 19,80 X | 11,00X | 19,09X | 19,24X | 18,80X | 15,00X | 17,60X |
| Eindsnelheid | 24,13X | 40,03X | 42,64 X | 34,15X | 42,67X | 43,01X | 42,05X | 31,85X | 30,67X |
| Type CLV/CAV | P-CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV | CAV |
| Disc Eject | 1,18 s | 3,33 s | 1,74 s | 1,64 s | 1,66 s | 1,86 s | 3,31 s | 3,29 s | 1,81 s |
| Disc load en recognition | 6,29 s | 10,79 s | 10,25 s | 7,66 s | 13,49 s | 11,06 s | 11,55 s | 8,58 s | 7,57 s |
| SCSI Mechanic 3.0 benchmarks | |||||||||
| Random I/O | 602 kB/s | 640 kB/s | 775 kB/s | 860 kB/s | 780 kB/s | 715 kB/s | 630 kB/s | 630 kB/s | 672 kB/s |
| Sequential I/O | 4050 kB/s | 4440 kB/s | 4510 kB/s | 4370 kB/s | 4500 kB/s | 3201 kB/s | 4400 kB/s | 4300 kB/s | 3250 kB/s |
| Same sector | 1450 kB/s | 1830 kB/s | 22690 kB/s | 25900 kB/s | 22765 kB/s | 3291 kB/s | 1775 kB/s | 1830 kB/s | 3355 kB/s |
| Geluidsniveau op 0,5 m | |||||||||
| lezen van CD | 57 dB | 63 dB | 57 dB | 59 dB | 57 dB | 53 dB | 55 dB | 55 dB | 62 dB |
| branden van CD | 51 dB | 57 dB | 55 dB | 57 dB | 56 dB | 51 dB | 51 dB | 52 dB | 52 dB |
| Meegeleverde | |||||||||
| software | Nero 5.5.2.2, InCD 2.1.4 | Nero 5.5.3.5, InCD 2.1.4 | Nero 5.5.3.2, InCD 2.0, HP Recordnow, HP DLA, Bonussoftware | Nero 5.5.3.0, InCD 2.0 | Nero 5.5.3.5, InCD 2.0, Plextools 1.09 | WinOnCd 3.8, Plextools | Prassi Primo CD Plus 2.0 (+ update) | Prassi Primo CD Plus 2.0 | Easy CD Creator 4.03d |
| Lege CDR / CDRW | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 | 1 / 1 |
| Bekabeling, etc. | audio kabeltje | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje, CD label kit | audio kabeltje | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje, pin, jumper | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje | SCSI kabel, audio kabeltje | IDE-kabel, audio kabeltje |
| Opmerkingen | Ventilator aan achterzijde | Ventilator aan achterzijde | Ventilator aan achterzijde | ||||||
| Adviesprijs in guldens | - | n.a. | fl. 599,- | fl. 479,- | fl. 593,81 | - | - | - | - |
| Adviesprijs in euro's | - | n.a. | 271,81 € | 217,36 € | 269,46 € | - | - | - | - |
| Distributeur(s) | Acer Communications & Mulimedia Benelux | McDos | Actebis Computers BV | Vito Computers BV | Actebis Computers BV | Actebis Computers BV | Karma Benelux BV | Karma Benelux BV | Quote Components |
Advertentie
